chris661
Money List Winner
^^^wot 'e said...........although I vote for the Scotty
best putter in you opinion?
- Thread starter golfstick
- Start date
^^^wot 'e said...........although I vote for the Scotty
JT77
Tour Winner
Try them both, you might find neither is right, or you may find you prefer the feel of one more than the other, I have a Scotty, but tried a friends ping and would have been happy to switch, and I love my Scotty!!
Imurg
The Grinder Of Pars (Semi Crocked)
Is the right answer.
Only way to.find out is try 'em
percy_layer
Challenge Tour Pro
If you prefer the Anser style then the Ping Redwood is the best by a long way.
The balance of the club is down to personal preference, some people like the head to be heavy, others like the grip end to be heavy. My advice is to get a putter fitting to find the length, lie and balance you prefer. In my opinion the putter is the most important club to be custom fitted.
Eyes over the ball or just inside
Hands under the shoulders
Putter head lies flush to the ground
The balance of the club is down to personal preference, some people like the head to be heavy, others like the grip end to be heavy. My advice is to get a putter fitting to find the length, lie and balance you prefer. In my opinion the putter is the most important club to be custom fitted.
Eyes over the ball or just inside
Hands under the shoulders
Putter head lies flush to the ground
SharkAttack
Q-School Graduate
Best putter has to be Ben Crenshaw with anything in his hands, even a Scotty (and that is a big disadvantage)
Shark
Shark
medwayjon
Tour Winner
Problem with a scotty is you are paying a huge premium for the branding.
Try the Taylor-Made Daytona AGSI, quality putter, paid £80 for mine and it is the style of putter you are talking about.
Try the Taylor-Made Daytona AGSI, quality putter, paid £80 for mine and it is the style of putter you are talking about.
ScienceBoy
Money List Winner
Ping redwood series by far
My Zing model and I couldnt miss today
When my stroke is good its the most amazing feeling, I can never blame the club, its always my stroke or green read.
My Zing model and I couldnt miss today
When my stroke is good its the most amazing feeling, I can never blame the club, its always my stroke or green read.
Owen_Thomas_14
Journeyman Pro
You feeling ok? the Beach putters are the best out there
D
Deleted member 1418
Guest
Have had both Scotty's and Pings and in my opinion the Pings just shade it.
However I actually think Odyssey are better than both and can see me having my current White Hot Tour #5 in the bag for quite a while.
However I actually think Odyssey are better than both and can see me having my current White Hot Tour #5 in the bag for quite a while.
hangover
Challenge Tour Pro
Yes are quality putters. The yes sophia putter will soon be a new addition to my bag
Yerman
Journeyman Pro
With putters that good its what feels best in your hands, its like asking which is better apple pie or rhubarb crumble, both are great, with custard of course. 
richart
Major Champion
Another shout for an Odyssey, i have a white hot xg #1 which is great especially on quick greens. Was well pleased when i tried a Scotty and didn't get on with it. Saved me a tidy sum.
Matty
Tour Rookie
I don't think there's a lot in it for me - why pay over the odds for essentially the same thing. So, Ping Answer for me.
But, I'll stick with my Odyssey Sabretooth as I'm getting great roll and distance with it at the moment!
But, I'll stick with my Odyssey Sabretooth as I'm getting great roll and distance with it at the moment!
r1965h
Club Champion
You feeling ok? the Beach putters are the best out there
It's all about personal preference, but for me the Ping is the better putter. If the Beach putters were the best out there all the pros would be using them and they aren't.
robbest3offthetee
Tour Rookie
Did nt a certain Mr TW use a Scotty for ALL of his wins,as everyone says its personal preference but imo Scotty cameron putters are fantastic,and thats after trying a Ping Redwood...
AuburnWarrior
Tour Winner
Cost doesn't matter though, does it???
Putting is all about confidence so if your putter costs £10 or £1,010, it's all immaterial as it's how the putter makes you feel that makes the difference.
The best putter I had was a Bronty GreenMaster IV (or something like that) when I was 13. It cost no more than £10 and I loved it.
Then it got nicked.........
Putting is all about confidence so if your putter costs £10 or £1,010, it's all immaterial as it's how the putter makes you feel that makes the difference.
The best putter I had was a Bronty GreenMaster IV (or something like that) when I was 13. It cost no more than £10 and I loved it.
Then it got nicked.........
Been through all manner of shapes and inserts trying to find "the one". Still got my original Anser 2 from the 80's which gets an outing every now and then but I think my Odyssey #9 is the best I've used for a very long time. I'm supremely confident with it especially on the 4-6 footers. I am not a huge Scotty fan and think you are paying way too much for the name and so would opt if I had to decide/ Cameron v Anser on the Ping
kev_off_the_tee
Journeyman Pro
I like the look of 2 or 3 YES putters but still have not had the chance to try them. I was impressed with my friends Odyssey Black Series No 1, Perfect weight and feel
bobmac
Major Champion
YES Callie 
Aztecs27
Money List Winner
YES Callie
As long as it has a shaft length of more than 15"
