D
Deleted Member 1156
Guest
Having quoted 33-1, here's a pragmatic thought. If you both agree - and tell no-one else apart from all the forummers here - to play the medal under strokeplay rules, and decide the outcome of each hole on the score achieved, you could have a matchplay outcome. Don't tell anyone else I suggested it.
I've heard of this being done before by a couple of guys at my previous club.
TBH, most club secretaries aren't really too interested in how a tie is decided, ignorance is bliss and all that, they just want to see all the matches completed by the deadline.