The 3BaysGSA - Golf Swing Analyzer (iOS Version)

[road2ruin]

So, before I start I'd just like to point out that I really don't think that this is going to turn me into Rory however I am a bit of a sucker for gadgets like this. Yes, also probably a case of more money than sense however I don't have any dependents (that I know of) and I'm making the most of having money going on things I want rather than more sensible avenues!!

This is going to be an ongoing review as whilst Yodel did manage to get the thing delivered it was 2 days late and pitch black by the time they arrived. I suppose I should just be grateful that it arrived at all, I've had plenty of things from Yodel that haven't!!

Anyway, just a few pics out of the box:

First thoughts are that it's quite a small thing so I'm pleased that they've included a box which will help when transporting from home to driving range etc. Also, whilst the pin is made of plastic it feels pretty sturdy and when fitting to the club I didn't feel as though I was just about to snap it or anything! I would suggest twisting in and out though rather than just pulling and pushing, don't want to tempt fate about the sturdiness!!

I bought the iOS version and the pairing with my iPhone was very straight forward. Just find the device on the iPhone's Bluetooth set up page and once connected enter 8888 and you're done.

Once on the club it doesn't feel any different and I don't find it distracting:

As already mentioned it's too dark for a proper test so I decided to just use a wedge and as the wife is at work I won't get caught and told off for damage to lampshades, carpet etc.

Having done that it just seems to be a case of swinging away! With the app loaded and running on the iPhone I had a couple of swings. Once a swing was complete the data from the device transferred in a matter of seconds so there was no hanging around for things to happen which was nice.

Obviously I haven't actually hit a ball, am inside and also trying not to ruin said lampshade so the following is pretty pointless for the time however it gives you an idea of how the data is displayed. Just to note, this is literally having had a 10 minute play so there is probably more to learn and hopefully I'll be able to have a proper go at the range tomorrow:

As I said, this is just an intro to something that is either going to be very useful/a good laugh or just something that will end up in my 'gadget' cupboard and will never see the light of day after a month or so!!

 

[G1BB0]

looks bloody good tbh, gadgets are great. I reckon just to check swing speed/tempo is decent enough tbh. (Just googled and I see its 199 sovs... ouch! but as you say no kids etc so why not)

It would be interesting to see it compared to an expensive device like flightscope etc just to see how accurate it really is.

Look forward to further updates :thup:

 

[jeardley]

Nice review mate, looking forward to seeing the follow up after the range session

 

[Mugs]

Funnily enough I was looking at this last week but couldn't find any reviews on it

Initial review looks good so far but looking forward to a more in depth update on this

 

[timchump]

thats looks really nice, i'm also very interested to see how you get on with it at the range

 

[G1BB0]

it seems theres a few of these type of devices, general feeling is that they are failry accurate and although not perfect, very good for improving your swing along with good instruction.

I googled this one and found some reviews on golfwrx etc

 

[granters]

I looked at one a few weeks ago ,I think it would be tremendous for practice,especially if shared with your pro. Hopefully next bonus time ....

 

[G1BB0]

granters, your sig, the yellow!! it hurts my eyes lol

 

[palindromicbob]

Interesting. Thanks Gordon the review. Will be keeping an eye on this. Do you have any possibility of comparing this to one of the big boys.

 

[HomerJSimpson]

OK a few questions. Do you actually understand what each facet means and do you know how to interpret them into your swing? My pro uses a launch monitor and with pro intervention I do have a better understanding with what some of the numbers mean to my swing and how it relates to the shot I've hit.

I'm not trying to rain on anyones parade but as one that has been accused of paralysis by analysis over the years, this seems another thing that would potentially get in the way of constructive practice when it becomes all about the numbers and not what the strike and flight of the ball are telling you

 

[palindromicbob]

Interesting. Thanks Gordon the review. Will be keeping an eye on this. Do you have any possibility of comparing this to one of the big boys.

sorry auto correct made for into Gordon somehow.

 

[USER1999]

Given that the device is stuck in the grip end of the club, how does shaft flex, length, kick point, torque etc effect the accuracy of the data?

 

[upsidedown]

Good bit of gadgetry , enjoy it.

 

[G1BB0]

Given that the device is stuck in the grip end of the club, how does shaft flex, length, kick point, torque etc effect the accuracy of the data?

it doesnt therfor it is purely a monitoring tool for structured practice and feedback. Thats why they say they dont replace launch monitors etc or proper fitting/lessons from a pro

 

[StrangelyBrown]

Thanks for posting R2R...

I'm not sure I know what it all means, but I know that I NEED one

Just have to wait for it to come out for 'droid instead of that filthy fruit-based operating system

 

[Phil2511]

I thought they did both versions.

 

[BTatHome]

Very interested to know the accuracy of the device. Simple physics says its very tight tolerances of angles etc at the grip end compared to the club head end, so I would amazed that it could accurately represent club head angle etc from data gathered at the grip end. It must also be told the club that it being used too? Is that somehow calibrated for "your" clubs, in terms of loft/lie/length. All of those must change quite a lot of the data.

 

[road2ruin]

Very interested to know the accuracy of the device. Simple physics says its very tight tolerances of angles etc at the grip end compared to the club head end, so I would amazed that it could accurately represent club head angle etc from data gathered at the grip end. It must also be told the club that it being used too? Is that somehow calibrated for "your" clubs, in terms of loft/lie/length. All of those must change quite a lot of the data.

Can't comment on the accuracy as yet although hoping to get out to the range at some point today (wife allowing). I have pretty consistent iron distances so I should be able to get an idea of how close this is to the real thing so to speak.

In terms of the calibration you have the option of adding in all your shaft lengths although there is nothing for loft/lie.

 

[road2ruin]

I thought they did both versions.

They do, an Android version is also available.

 

[road2ruin]

OK a few questions. Do you actually understand what each facet means and do you know how to interpret them into your swing? My pro uses a launch monitor and with pro intervention I do have a better understanding with what some of the numbers mean to my swing and how it relates to the shot I've hit.

I'm not trying to rain on anyones parade but as one that has been accused of paralysis by analysis over the years, this seems another thing that would potentially get in the way of constructive practice when it becomes all about the numbers and not what the strike and flight of the ball are telling you

The short answer is no when it comes to understanding everything that is on there (at this point) however I haven't bought it to start analysing my swing to the nth degree. The initial reason for getting it is to get pretty instant feedback on my swing when I'm not having a lesson. This allows me to put into practice what I'm being taught and hopefully check that I am doing it correctly rather than just assuming that I am applying the changes. I also have a habit of swinging too quickly so this will act as a reminder with the tempo stats.

As I said at the beginning I'm not expecting this to be a cure all but I can see it helping me when I'm on my own.