• We'd like to take this opportunity to wish you a Happy Holidays and a very Merry Christmas from all at Golf Monthly. Thank you for sharing your 2025 with us!

Premier League 2019-2020 we’re off

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 15344
  • Start date Start date
Until the VAR goes the same way as the rugby then it will continue to be a shambles. The video ref should be in the main referees ear.
Get some screens in the stadium for the replays too.

It’s beggars belief that the on field ref can’t just run over to a screen and watch a replay.
 
It’s beggars belief that the on field ref can’t just run over to a screen and watch a replay.
It should be like Rugby where the ref and the video bod talk to each other while reviewing the incident on a big screen which everyone can see.
It’s worked well for years that way on rugby.
 
Goals change matches and so if City got the penalty (I think they should have) and gone 1-0 up then a totally different scenario. That said the second two Liverpool goals have been really good and no qualms. Does simply question how good VAR is and why is it so inconsistent so what is given one week is not given the next when looking at the pictures appears to the neutral at home exactly the same. Sadly today in what is arguably the biggest game of the season they have got it badly wrong. That said Liverpool have been the better side throughout but how different could it have been?
 
😂😂😂
neither were a penalty.

Think we need to disagree early on. First one I thought was a clear penalty especially when you see the hand is in an unnatural position under the current guidance. I though at the very least the referee should have looked at it. Clearly you disagree and I respect that so we'll hold our opinions and differ
 
Think we need to disagree early on. First one I thought was a clear penalty especially when you see the hand is in an unnatural position under the current guidance. I though at the very least the referee should have looked at it. Clearly you disagree and I respect that so we'll hold our opinions and differ

First one, it hit the city players arm first
 
VAR took 3.5 minutes to disallow a Sheffield United goal for no real reason yesterday.

Today, within 10 seconds, 2 handballs were decided, and there was none of that line drawing check on Salah for offside.

Where is the consistency?

VAR is causing more issues than it’s worth imo.

I agree. The offside today was near identical to yesterday and yet one took 3.5 mins to decide and the other 3.5 secs. I’d argue that the line for the ’offside’ wasn't correctly drawn today.

Being clear, the team with the better defence won today.
 
Top