sawtooth
Tour Winner
So now that we are back to competition golf under the new WHS handicapping system, how will you be applying penalty scores to golfers?
I had 4 cards yesterday, 1 NR'd a single hole but otherwise carded a full medal score, 3 others however abandoned scoring altogether on hole 7, hole 9 and hole 15.
I've read through all of the WHS guidance and its not very clear.
"
Reason : Penalty Score Non-valid reason (e.g. memory or not realising a score had to be returned in such situations as injury, failing light, dangerous weather etc.)
Penalty Score: A score equivalent to the current Handicap Index should be submitted to the WHS Platform (i.e. an Adjusted Gross Score which would be equivalent to the Course Rating + Course Handicap).
Reason: Possible attempt to keep handicap low
Penalty Score : A score equivalent to the Adjusted Gross Score of the highest return in the last 20 scores should be submitted to the WHS Platform.
Reason: Possible attempt to build a handicap
Penalty Score: A score equivalent to the Adjusted Gross Score of the lowest return in the last 20 scores should be submitted to the WHS Platform.
"
Above is all well and good but its really hard to tell what the genuine motives are for people.
For now, I think I will write to each player and just remind them of their responsibilities. Having a bad day is not an acceptable reason for not carding a score. Injury is however, so they should state that on the card. I intend to keep a record of names (not sure if HandicapMaster has a report for this or not) and will probably look to take action if the same names keep offending. When do you decide enough is enough though?
One part of me is saying that we need to meet our obligations to WHS, another part is saying why are we telling people to carry on playing golf when they are having a bad day and making spoiling enjoyment for others? I'm a little confused by it all, if someone really wanted to manipulate the system they could still just deliberately card doubles, triples, quadruples and complete all holes, and avoid detection so what's the point of it all?
I had 4 cards yesterday, 1 NR'd a single hole but otherwise carded a full medal score, 3 others however abandoned scoring altogether on hole 7, hole 9 and hole 15.
I've read through all of the WHS guidance and its not very clear.
"
Reason : Penalty Score Non-valid reason (e.g. memory or not realising a score had to be returned in such situations as injury, failing light, dangerous weather etc.)
Penalty Score: A score equivalent to the current Handicap Index should be submitted to the WHS Platform (i.e. an Adjusted Gross Score which would be equivalent to the Course Rating + Course Handicap).
Reason: Possible attempt to keep handicap low
Penalty Score : A score equivalent to the Adjusted Gross Score of the highest return in the last 20 scores should be submitted to the WHS Platform.
Reason: Possible attempt to build a handicap
Penalty Score: A score equivalent to the Adjusted Gross Score of the lowest return in the last 20 scores should be submitted to the WHS Platform.
"
Above is all well and good but its really hard to tell what the genuine motives are for people.
For now, I think I will write to each player and just remind them of their responsibilities. Having a bad day is not an acceptable reason for not carding a score. Injury is however, so they should state that on the card. I intend to keep a record of names (not sure if HandicapMaster has a report for this or not) and will probably look to take action if the same names keep offending. When do you decide enough is enough though?
One part of me is saying that we need to meet our obligations to WHS, another part is saying why are we telling people to carry on playing golf when they are having a bad day and making spoiling enjoyment for others? I'm a little confused by it all, if someone really wanted to manipulate the system they could still just deliberately card doubles, triples, quadruples and complete all holes, and avoid detection so what's the point of it all?