Homer
Active member
Who?
My first boo boo under the new rules
- Thread starter jim8flog
- Start date
Who?
Wolf
Well-known member
I honestly don't get the issue with knee height drops.
Most people bend forward to address a ball, they tend to bend further forward to address a putt and had to bend right over to put a tee in the ground. If you can do any of these then to simply extend the arm to drop from knee height is unbelievably simple.
I've seen so many people trying to contort sideways to do it when you really don't have to
Most people bend forward to address a ball, they tend to bend further forward to address a putt and had to bend right over to put a tee in the ground. If you can do any of these then to simply extend the arm to drop from knee height is unbelievably simple.
I've seen so many people trying to contort sideways to do it when you really don't have to
Last edited:
Homer
Active member
This!
Slab
Occasional Tour Caddy
Yeah I'm happy with the knee drop
I have a half circle to drop in so I won't really be dropping it at the front edge of that area so it's unlikely to roll closer
It's going about one third the speed of a shoulder drop so it generally has one tiny bounce and settles within a couple of inches of impact point, if would need a brutal slope to go further
I have a half circle to drop in so I won't really be dropping it at the front edge of that area so it's unlikely to roll closer
It's going about one third the speed of a shoulder drop so it generally has one tiny bounce and settles within a couple of inches of impact point, if would need a brutal slope to go further
Saw a double hit on Wednesday that looked dubious but I guess the new rules cover it. A guy hit his putt from about a foot and it looked like he'd under hit it but the exaggerated follow through/flick saw it into the hole.
Maybe you had to be there to gauge how bad it looked but it just didn't sit right.
Maybe you had to be there to gauge how bad it looked but it just didn't sit right.
jusme
Challenge Tour Pro
sounds like a push/cheat shot
duncan mackie
Money List Winner
If he's redropping because of incorrect procedure (as posted) you aren't in the cycle you indicate regarding where the ball finishes.
As to the concept of not near enough to knee height...i thought the ruling bodies had made it clear enough that it's not supposed to be a science. The fact that with any slope the actual height between where it's released and the ground can legally vary quite significantly at the choice of the player shows this well.
It's blindingly obvious when a player is trying to drop from his knee height - that's good enough to get on with the game.
As and when conditions dry out the difference in outcomes will also change dramatically (between knee and shoulder height) - right now the differences aren't as great; on any significant slope it's going to be a redrop anyway, and on the flat, dropped in the middle of the relief area, either will probably remain in.
Yes, old habits are hard to break - but new golfers won't have them and the rest will get used to it.
duncan mackie
Money List Winner
Another case where it's usually blindingly obvious whether the club head has re-routed (line or subsequent acceleration) after the first contact, making it a stroke at a moving ball rather than a double hit.
Orikoru
Tour Winner
It may not be to everyone's taste but I don't think it's actually significant enough to be upset about. You just drop it and move on. I would never ever make someone redrop it to get the precise knee height, that is ridiculous. If someone drops it from 6 inches above their knee what difference does it make to me? Let's just get on with it. If they dropped it from waist/shoulder height I'd remind them it's meant to be knee height, but that's it.
Last edited:
I did ask but it then became yes you did no you didn't discussion. Another player approached me in the car park afterwards and asked if I was going to sign the card. As you know, not signing doesn't make any difference. At least his 19pts didn't trouble the scoreboard.
Jacko_G
Blackballed
Love this association I have with the mythical one. Considering I've never met the man/woman let alone spoken to them!
😂😂😂
You stick to your Ping bashing threads I can handle them.
drdel
Tour Rookie
The changes were to aid the pace of play and simplify the game. Since we get to 'place' after two drops and a roll back why not place it in the first place within the permitted zone no nearer the hole?
jim8flog
Journeyman Pro
That's something that has not really changed I know loads of players who, apparently, were incapable of dropping from shoulder height, me included on occasions.
6535
Newbie
A whole 18hrs without a mod editing your post. You've done well ðŸ‘
TheJezster
Tour Rookie
I dont understand people who cant 'get' what knee height means. Everyone has knees, we all know where they are. Simply bend down enough to have the ball at around your own knees height and drop the bloody thing!
It's really as simple as that. Grown men bleating about this is honestly just nonsense, if ever the term man up should be used, it's now!
It's really as simple as that. Grown men bleating about this is honestly just nonsense, if ever the term man up should be used, it's now!
jim8flog
Journeyman Pro
You wait until you get to my age with my injuries.
On second thoughts I hope you never have those injuries.
Jacko_G
Blackballed
Like every change(s) they will take time to bed in and become second nature.
backwoodsman
Tour Winner
Here's a thought for those who claim problems with dropping from knee height....
After you've bent down to pick your ball up, just do the the drop as the ball passes knee height on your way back up to standing... ???
After you've bent down to pick your ball up, just do the the drop as the ball passes knee height on your way back up to standing... ???
