Cardrona Golf & Country Club, Peebles. I don't get it!

John_Findlay

Tour Winner
Joined
Jan 15, 2007
Messages
3,487
Location
Edinburgh
Visit site
I played here the other day with a couple of pals. Snow on the sides of the road on the way down. Not looking good. Full waterproofs expected.

Got there and it's flat calm and after two holes the sun's out and the windcheater and the woolly hat had to come off or I'd boil to death. Lovely day. Glorious for March.

I don't get it. I've heard nothing but bad reports about this course but I just don't understand that at all. I thought it was a great track. I'd recommend it to anyone, especially at £20 a round whilst they're doing winter rates. Summer is around £60, I think, which is probably a little steep for me.

The course is picturesque, has a great variety of interesting holes all the way round (with the exception of maybe 2 of the par 5s on the back 9 which were ordinary), great bunker placement, a bit of water. You name it. I was well impressed.

The greens were scarified that day but they were firm and undulating and should be fast in the summer.

It's a decent length on some holes. Examples. I creamed a Sunday best drive off the 3rd, well past my playing partners, and still had a full 3 iron in. And on the 7th (lovely hole) a good drive over the burn left me with a full 5 wood on to the green. In a wind that's gonna be harsh.

I'll let you judge for yourselves if you've not played it. I took video of every hole. YouTube vids of the front 9 and the back 9.

:D

Cardrona. Holes 1-9

Cardrona. Holes 10-18

Oh. Food in the attached Macdonald Cardrona Hotel was all very nice but expensive. £5.80 for soup. Ouch. I had fish and chips. £12 I think.

Anyway, the best thing was that we played and ate for free. Golf is always more enjoyable that way, don't you think? Scott's connections with the 59 Club. Yayyy.

Didn't play very well. Started par, birdie, par.....and finished birdie, par, par. We won't talk about the 12 in the middle. 28 points. Got gubbed by Scott on 37 points (off 8) and Gerry on 33 points (off 18) . Boo.

:D
 
Sounds good John. Playing there with my wife next month. Like you I've heard horror stories about it, but it's always looked okay when I've passed by. First chance I've had to play it.
 
thanks

nice to hear a decent review of the course - like a lot on here i've heard that it's only good for cattle grazing - I'll check out your vids when I get home

the only thing I have against it is - a few years ago I took HID there for a weekend and was refused entry to the Restaurant without a Jacket & Tie - had to borrow one from the Concierge!!
 
....like a lot on here i've heard that it's only good for cattle grazing

Exactly what we'd heard. Nonsense. The three of us agreed we'd be back in a shot.

Yes, we had criticisms (Scott had to write a fairly detailed report), especially about the service in the Hotel but no complaints about the course for this time of year. It was very playable and as much fun as I've had on a golf course in a while. I might baulk at paying the Summer rate...but that's just me.
 
Ah... the good old days ;)

the only thing I have against it is - a few years ago I took HID there for a weekend and was refused entry to the Restaurant without a Jacket & Tie - had to borrow one from the Concierge!!

Smart casual seems to suffice nowadays.
 
Nah. Not always. The low ball hitter plays at Craigielaw in East Lothian where it's very windy. Think he's been working on hitting the drives low. Don't think the other 2 of us do, though, unless we try (or thin it).
 
Just a typical resort course....like Linden Hall it suffers from drainage problems,although USGA spec greens help.If the conditions are good under foot it's a decent layout and makes for an enjoyable game aslong as your not paying top dollar.
 
Dodger, it's head and shoulders above Bamburgh. There you are. But as Ivan says I'd be irked at paying top dollar. £40-£45 tops and you wouldnt feel disappointed though.
 
Nice review JF, i'd agree that it looks to be a bargain at £20....and some great scenery to go with it !!
 
Dodger, it's head and shoulders above Bamburgh. There you are. But as Ivan says I'd be irked at paying top dollar. £40-£45 tops and you wouldnt feel disappointed though.

As it happens I would rather play Bamburgh!!

Head and shoulders...come on John,it's another run of the mill Thomas track,nothing more nothing less.
 
Yeah, there are some long walks between greens and tees but pleasant enough on a nice day.

Dodger, we can debate it all we want but that's the benefit of a video review, I suppose. A picture paints a thousand words, as they say.

It's still better than Dalmahoy.

:p :p :p
 
Have driven by a few times recently with work, looks like a nice track from the road and backed up by ths video. Attractive part of the country too.

A wee pull on the 1st tee there JF? ;)

For £20, you can't lose.
 
Exactly Stuart. As I said, I'd not be unhappy paying £40-45 in the summer when you pay nearly that for such places as Gullane 2 and 3. It was very enjoyable.

Yeah, a wee low draw pull on 1. I was suffering from a bit of a hangover after celebrating my girlfriend's birthday the night before. When my friend picked me up in the car we stopped for drinks and fuel at a petrol station on the way down and when I got back into the car I found myself sitting in the driver's seat wondering why I didn't have a key and all the controls were different. I wasn't quite "with it" for the first few holes shall we say.

Needless to say my best shots weren't on camera. They missed my best drives and the two birdies. My pals are sacked as videographers. Seems they can't press an "on" button.

:p
 
Top