Still disagree but prepared to accept others have their own preferences. Its out of my price bracket for the moment anyway but remains on the wish list
Gave up on my odyssey #5 this year. Always struggle with it early season when greens are slow but this year just could not get a consistent strike on it at all. Was worried my Bettinardi would be a bit hot off the face but i am very happy with it. Have to stick to a pro v with it though
Homer I have the Black series no.1 (not the i one you tested) and I think it is a super putter. When I bought it I had actually went in to buy a scotty but preferred the weight of the odyssey and the thicker grip. I have it around two years and imagine will keep it for a long time. As we all know if you have confidence in your putter then you will putt well.(most of the time anyway)