• Thank you all very much for sharing your time with us in 2025. We hope you all have a safe and happy 2026!

Madeleine McCann

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 15344
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
PhilTheFragger said:
Conspiracy theory at it's best
No evidence, no charges, no nuffin

Is this the same bloke who was sacked for being grossly incompetent ?

I hope for some sort of closure on this, but agree with others opinions that the parents weren't responsible for her disappearance

BUT none of us know the whole story, so we need the judicial process to grind it's wheels a bit more
Click to expand...

I think they were certainly partly responsible for her disappearance. I do hope they catch the culprit/s whoever that may be and their is some sort of closure, but let's not pretend the parents are blameless in this.

Bloody criminal leaving your kids like that, criminal!
 
c1973 said:
I think they were certainly partly responsible for her disappearance. I do hope they catch the culprit/s whoever that may be and their is some sort of closure, but let's not pretend the parents are blameless in this.

Bloody criminal leaving your kids like that, criminal!
Click to expand...

I didn't say they were blameless, they were negligent,
But to suggest their active involvement based on what we know is simply wrong
 
PhilTheFragger said:
I didn't say they were blameless, they were negligent,
But to suggest their active involvement based on what we know is simply wrong
Click to expand...


Sorry, I thought when you said they weren't responsible for her disappearance it indicated a lack of blame on their part.
Crossed wires perhaps.
 
freddielong said:
There are people out there convinced we haven't been to the moon it doesn't make it true. Everyone is entitled to there own opinion but you cannot have your own facts.
Click to expand...

It's a very interesting case. Two British police dogs, who have never been wrong on over 200 occasions, detected traces of Madeline's dead body & blood in the apartment and in the back of the McCann's hire car. One of the dogs is so expert it is hired out to other police forces and earns more per annum than the Chief Constable! Also, there is a reliable witness who says he saw a person he's adamant was Gerry Mc.Cann carrying a child through the town after her disappearance. In addition, Kate McCann answered "no comment" to 48 questions put to her by the police when they were trying to find out what happened, ages before they were declared suspects. There are many other aspects of the Mc. Canns' behaviour that are hard to explain. I really don't know but there are many people who think that there is much more to this case than has so far come out.

And I did make my original post in response to someone who said that "no sane, rational person" would believe the parents were responsible for her disappearance. They may be wrong but a lot of them are sane & rational.
 
Papas1982 said:
you were implying that it's only low life that read that paper. Whilst I totally get why you don't like the paper. Not everyone reading it fits the criteria you presented.
Click to expand...


Not everyone but going to say a fair few

Should be out of business just like the NOTW
 
Maninblack4612 said:
It's a very interesting case. Two British police dogs, who have never been wrong on over 200 occasions, detected traces of Madeline's dead body & blood in the apartment and in the back of the McCann's hire car. One of the dogs is so expert it is hired out to other police forces and earns more per annum than the Chief Constable! Also, there is a reliable witness who says he saw a person he's adamant was Gerry Mc.Cann carrying a child through the town after her disappearance. In addition, Kate McCann answered "no comment" to 48 questions put to her by the police when they were trying to find out what happened, ages before they were declared suspects. There are many other aspects of the Mc. Canns' behaviour that are hard to explain. I really don't know but there are many people who think that there is much more to this case than has so far come out.

And I did make my original post in response to someone who said that "no sane, rational person" would believe the parents were responsible for her disappearance. They may be wrong but a lot of them are sane & rational.
Click to expand...

I dont know what to think about this case , there has been so many false lead and conspiracy theories. Thankfully abduction cases like this are extremely rare which is probably why the McCann's were under suspicion from day one. As in an most murder cases the perpetrator is usually a family member or is at least known to the victim. Something struck me at the time about McCann's body language which I thought was odd, perhaps they didnt look grief stricken enough? - I'm not sure what it was.

That said in the absence of hard evidence they are innocent, stupid but innocent.
 
I think there is more theories about Madeline going missing than the JFK shooting

I have read the theories that they accidentally killed Her and then covered it up but the timings just don't seem to be able to fit


And wasn't the guy with the child in his arms another holiday maker picking up his sleeping child from a night crèche
 
Liverpoolphil said:
Not everyone but going to say a fair few

Should be out of business just like the NOTW
Click to expand...

With due respect I read the Sun? Do I fall under this sweeping judgement. I understand why you have an issue against the Sun but I resent any implication of being a chav or on benefit. These generalisations are unwarranted and unfair and don't help aid the thread. I acutally know guys who lost their job on the NOTW and have struggled financially since.
 
HomerJSimpson said:
With due respect I read the Sun? Do I fall under this sweeping judgement. I understand why you have an issue against the Sun but I resent any implication of being a chav or on benefit. These generalisations are unwarranted and unfair and don't help aid the thread. I acutally know guys who lost their job on the NOTW and have struggled financially since.
Click to expand...

Any paper that phone taps into Millie Dowlers phone messages and listens to them amongst other people deserves to go out of business and they should have been sent down

The sooner the sun follows it the better
 
Liverpoolphil said:
Any paper that phone taps into Millie Dowlers phone messages and listens to them amongst other people deserves to go out of business and they should have been sent down

The sooner the sun follows it the better
Click to expand...

Can we keep newspaper semantics out of this thread please, it does nobody any favours

Thanks
 
Liverpoolphil said:
Any paper that phone taps into Millie Dowlers phone messages and listens to them amongst other people deserves to go out of business and they should have been sent down

The sooner the sun follows it the better
Click to expand...

I didn't say what SOME people did was right ethical or legal. However as a result a lot of others who had worked there for many years lost their job. As I said, some I know had a hard time financially trying to get employment after as the NOTW mud stuck
 
Maninblack4612 said:
It's a very interesting case. Two British police dogs, who have never been wrong on over 200 occasions, detected traces of Madeline's dead body & blood in the apartment and in the back of the McCann's hire car. One of the dogs is so expert it is hired out to other police forces and earns more per annum than the Chief Constable! Also, there is a reliable witness who says he saw a person he's adamant was Gerry Mc.Cann carrying a child through the town after her disappearance. In addition, Kate McCann answered "no comment" to 48 questions put to her by the police when they were trying to find out what happened, ages before they were declared suspects. There are many other aspects of the Mc. Canns' behaviour that are hard to explain. I really don't know but there are many people who think that there is much more to this case than has so far come out.

And I did make my original post in response to someone who said that "no sane, rational person" would believe the parents were responsible for her disappearance. They may be wrong but a lot of them are sane & rational.
Click to expand...

These are indeed phenomenal dogs, did they write down these 'facts' or bark out the letters spelling out Madeline, dead body, blood in a code only known to the handler?:confused:
Where did you get the statement the dog earns more than the Chief Constable?
 
sawtooth said:
I dont know what to think about this case , there has been so many false lead and conspiracy theories. Thankfully abduction cases like this are extremely rare which is probably why the McCann's were under suspicion from day one. As in an most murder cases the perpetrator is usually a family member or is at least known to the victim. Something struck me at the time about McCann's body language which I thought was odd, perhaps they didnt look grief stricken enough? - I'm not sure what it was.

That said in the absence of hard evidence they are innocent, stupid but innocent.
Click to expand...

I saw an interesting program that said in some cases when the people who eventually were found out to have 'done the crime' mostly give themselves away by over doing the grief stricken histrionics at press conferences. And police have a body language experts who can tell pretty well if the person in the press conference pleading for the return of a child/person is genuine or not, which helps the police direct the investigation. And in most occasions they turn out to be right.

They also said that people do react in different ways to a shock like this, and it's a bit of a cliche that everyone will/should turn into an emotional sobbing wreck if they are innocent. Some people just process the emotions in different ways.

But I'm in no way saying this has anything to do with the guilt or not of the McCann's, as I just don't know.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top