Golf GPS

chipsandegg

Head Pro
Joined
Jun 25, 2008
Messages
258
Visit site
Hi everyone,
I just wanted to tell you guys of my experience at the end of last year using a Sky Caddie. The pro at my club asked me would i play with him in a pro-am competition and naturally i jumped at the chance. Once we arrived at where we playing and sorted everything out we went to Tee Off, as we were walking to the 1st he told me we would use this and showed me his GPS something id never used before.Anyway to cut a long story short i hit it a little bit farther than the pro so when it came to taking our second shots into the green more often than not i was waiting for him to come and tell me the exact yardages. While i was waiting i already had it in my head what club i would be using going off the course markers and the by what the pin position appeared to be but to my surprise nearly every time he came over and told me the exact yardage i was sometimes up to 3 clubs out!!! Anyway, the result was we won with 45 points. The pro only used his score once (which was a chip in birdie and i parred it anyway). When we were back at the club house having our meal My partner worked out that i actually shot 73.Its a course ive never played on and off the whites in pretty damp mizzley conditions. Now im not saying this was purley down to the Sky Caddie as the way i was playing last year i was striking the ball really well but my short game was terrible (3 putting everything) but i wonder what my score would have been had i just gone with my gut instincts when selecting my irons? Since i played in this comp (last November) i did a bit of research on the net and bought myself a sonocaddie Autoplay and i have shot really good scores since. I couldnt believe the different way i played my own course.The best thing i find with the GPS is it tells you how many yards of green you have beyond the pin for me it took every little bit of doubt out of my head before playing my approach shot.
 
I have to agree, I have recently started using a GPS (must get around to reviewing it in the review section) and when you are standing over the ball thinking it's about so far and you check your GPS it's amazing how far out your own estimation can be. Since using mine unless I chunk one I do not come up short anymore and I'm hitting far more par 3's through correct clubbing. Anyone teetering on the edge of ordering one, get one, you will not be disappointed.
 
I don't have one but I find it very interesting you say you are playing your home track a lot differently to what you were. I suppose it's made it a different course.
Is it always that you estimate less than actual reading or does the variation go both ways?
 
I don't have one but I find it very interesting you say you are playing your home track a lot differently to what you were. I suppose it's made it a different course.
Is it always that you estimate less than actual reading or does the variation go both ways?

I mean different say as regards laying up. im finding im not using my driver as much and maybe playing upto hazards as opposed to trying to knock it past. Also with the GPS i opted for you have 3 distances for pin positions (they all might have them im not sure) so when ur working out your shot in you can set it for front middle or back and at my home course some of the greens are maybe 2 or 3 clubs deep. Usually i am finding im way underestimating just how far i need to go and say if im in 2 minds whether to hit say a 5 or 6 in and i know the pins in the middle of the green and i have 10-15 yards of green beyond the pin i can confidently take a 5 wheras before if i had gone with the 5 i would have had tinges of doubt in my mind when taking the shot and more often than not duff it.
 
Unless I know the pin is front or back on a particular green I generally go with the middle distance. That way, if I hit it well I'll be at the back of the green at worst and if I don't catch it quite right then the front is a possibility.
I find it more useful when (not if!) i go offline into the rough - you still know a distance without having to pace it.
 
I'm intrigued.
Previously you were taking clubs you thought were correct for the distance but after shooting a 73 knowing the right distances (a shot or two over par I'm guessing) you are sold on GPS.
Great. :)

What were you doing before? Not bothering to work it out and guessing/feeling the shot?
 
Unless I know the pin is front or back on a particular green I generally go with the middle distance. That way, if I hit it well I'll be at the back of the green at worst and if I don't catch it quite right then the front is a possibility.
I find it more useful when (not if!) i go offline into the rough - you still know a distance without having to pace it.

I'm pleased you commented on this, because I've been keen to share an interesting thought/discovery on here.

I always used to hit the club for the middle distance (since I used the 150 marker or strokesaver) and if in doubt, club up. e.g. If I paced it out and it's 132 (in between), I'd probably hit an 8 not a 9 and so on. Most of my regulars comment on how I often go long when I pick the wrong club. This is OK to an extent but a little frustrating. I don't think it would happen on courses with bigger greens.

BUT, recently I have been reading and noting the back distances using GPS. So, instead of automatically hitting a club up, I read the back and weigh up my options. This really gives confidence to hit the "club up" properly or not, as it were. Worrying you are holding too much club is not good for your shot, knowing you're never going over the back is great...especially in this weather when the ball plugs on landing.
 
I have always been a firm GPS advocate and I can understand what the OP is saying (although it sounds like his pro had a shocker in the pro-am to only come in once). It does make a huge difference when a green can be 30+ yards long. Depending on wind direction that could be a two club difference for me depending on if the flag is front or back.

At the end of the day everyone on here has their own opinion on these devices and all the DMD threads show a clear pro and anti divide. They are here to stay for the foreseeable future at least and are a godsend especially on an new course and so I guess those that already use them will continue to use them and those that don't will relish playing from yardage markers and strokesavers and judging by sight. Neither way is right or wrong and at the end of the day its about personal choice
 
I wouldn't be without mine. They are brilliant on a course you haven't played before and even on your own course when you wander off the beaten track.
 
Whats DMD standing for??

I'd love to re-measure a few of the holes at our track, and a few fairway markers. Just to check, you know.
 
There's no can't get one. Mine doesn't allow for comps but it's perfectly legal for practice, so using one will refine your distances - you'll know which markers are out.

If you play away it's distinctly better to have one than not.
 
i can see them being of benefit on an away track, but on your home track you should know the distances from most lies. the most important thing is gut feeling and understanding the weather, ground conditions, windage etc. they just tell you a distance. more accurate coarse distances and 150 markers are a help. we have a down hill par 3, [180 ish] driver into a strong wind pitching wedge with a tail wind, still the same distance. do not think they should be allowed in comps though, after all i cant have a temp gauge telling me i am hot or cold, the thermals and another three layers and hand warmers give me a clue though. will i get one, one day i expect but too many other things to waste my money on at the moment. :D
 
Top