Another example of why Insurance is important.

Dodger

Blackballed
Banned
Joined
Aug 20, 2007
Messages
9,083
Location
An underground bunker
Visit site
Interesting story from Scotland.:(


BLINDED BALL-SPOTTER SUES GAVIN DEAR FOR £50,000


Murrayshall House Hotel, near Perth's tour professional Gavin Dear, a former Walker Cup player, is being sued by a golf tournament ball-spotter for £50,000 damages after he was struck and blinded in one eye by a shot from the Scone-based golfer.
The incident happened in the 2009 Scottish Champion of Champions' Tournament, organised by the Leven Golfers' Society over the Leven links in Fife.
David McMahon, 70, of Leven has raised the action at the Court of Session in Edinburgh. Dear turned professional later in 2009.
Mr McMahon said he approach a couple of spectators who had strayed off a path and asked them to move as they were in danger of being struck by a golf ball.
As Mr McMahon turned to return to his buggy he was hit in the eye by a ball struck by Mr Dear at the sixth hole.
"The ball hit me and I went down," he said in court. "I covered my eye with my glove. I took my glove away and it was full of blood."
He told his counsel, Rnald Clancy QC, that he did not hear anyone shout a warning. The retired bus driver said it was the ninth time he had been struck on a golf course.
Mr McMahon denied that he was behind the buggy and emerged into the path of the ball when questioned by Graham Primrose, QC for the golfer.
It is alleged that Mr Dear knew or ought to have known that Mr McMahon was in line with the path of his shot and that had the golfer exercised reasonable care, ball-spotter Mr McMahon would not have been injured.
Mr Dear, 28, maintains that nobody was visible to him or his playing partner when he played his second shot from light rough at the par-5 hole.
He claims that he did see a buggy but there was no sign of any person.
Mr Dear's defence is that he acted at all times with reasonable care.
The hearing, before Lord Jones, continues.
 

jason6r

Assistant Pro
Joined
Apr 12, 2009
Messages
148
Location
Dedham, Essex
Visit site
Which raises the thought that he is as much, if not more of the problem than the golfer.

Exactly my thoughts!

Seriously, I've often thought about getting specialist golf insurance but never actually got round to it. However for what it costs vs what it would cost potentially in legal fees/damages plus the fact that I will play many more times this year than previously makes me think I will pay up for it.
 

HomerJSimpson

Hall of Famer
Joined
Aug 6, 2007
Messages
70,585
Location
Bracknell - Berkshire
Visit site
In the current climate this is going to increase. If the guy has been hit 9 times you have to wonder if he had tried to claim before and this time he really was in the wrong place at the wrong time. I wouldn't wish serious injury on anyone but there seems to be a lack of care by the claimant especially if he was emerging from behind a buggy and therefore unseen by the players.

I have had insurance for a while. To be honest if my gear gets nicked it's a pain but wouldn't be the end of the world. Hitting someone and getting a six figure bill for compensation is.
 

Bobirdie

Journeyman Pro
Joined
Aug 25, 2008
Messages
1,510
Location
Greenock,Scotland
www.williamsdoubleglazing.co.uk
Crazy.if he went to warn folk the possibiliy of being struck by a ball he obviously new the danger and to be hired/ volunteered as a ball spotter obviously wasnt very good as he never seen it coming. Only kidding that was below the belt. Surely if you are a ball spotter its at your own risk
 

Imurg

The Grinder Of Pars (Semi Crocked)
Joined
Mar 15, 2008
Messages
36,945
Location
Aylesbury Bucks
Visit site
If he is being "employed" as a ball spotter by a Tournament Committee surely that Committee must have Insurance in place to cover eventualities like this? He's being employed even if he only gets paid with a hat and a food voucher...
If you send people out into a potentially damaging environment you have to have some form of insurance - he should be caiming from them....
 

Rooter

Money List Winner
Joined
Jan 30, 2012
Messages
10,807
Location
Newbury
Visit site
I have had insurance for a while. To be honest if my gear gets nicked it's a pain but wouldn't be the end of the world. Hitting someone and getting a six figure bill for compensation is.

Exactly the same as me, clubs are on house insurance, its all about the liability for me. we are living in a blame someone else society. It wont be long before insurance is mandatory for all players whether that's covered in members subs or visitors have to prove private cover. And to be honest, i wouldn't moan if this was brought in... would free up my local cheap courses as the chavs would soon disappear!
 

Shaunmg

Head Pro
Joined
Apr 15, 2009
Messages
392
Location
St.Helens
Visit site
Exactly the same as me, clubs are on house insurance, its all about the liability for me. we are living in a blame someone else society. It wont be long before insurance is mandatory for all players whether that's covered in members subs or visitors have to prove private cover. And to be honest, i wouldn't moan if this was brought in... would free up my local cheap courses as the chavs would soon disappear!

I have insurance, but one sure way of tripling the cost of golf insurance is to make it mandatory. Car insurance tells you that
 

woody69

Journeyman Pro
Joined
Sep 7, 2012
Messages
2,676
Visit site
Off tppic but could you sue someone for breaking your ankle in a game of ameture football??? Doubt it you know the risk

Of course you could. If you suffered loss of earnings from such an injury you could sue the person who injured you and the owner of the venue in which the injury occurred depending on the circumstances. You might not necessarily win, but you could sue.
 

One Planer

Global Moderator
Joined
Feb 11, 2011
Messages
13,430
Location
Modsville
Visit site
If he is being "employed" as a ball spotter by a Tournament Committee surely that Committee must have Insurance in place to cover eventualities like this? He's being employed even if he only gets paid with a hat and a food voucher...
If you send people out into a potentially damaging environment you have to have some form of insurance - he should be caiming from them....

I'm with Ian on this :thup:

Surely the course/organisers have to have some form of liability insurance in place for a tournament.
 

Akie

Head Pro
Joined
Dec 18, 2012
Messages
306
Location
Manchester
Visit site
Off tppic but could you sue someone for breaking your ankle in a game of ameture football??? Doubt it you know the risk

Marcus Hallows from Altrincham FC successfully sued Ashton Utd FC as one of their players ended his playing career. They were ordered to pay £32,000 for the leg breaking tackle that the referee didn't even call a foul, not sure if they ever actually paid it.
 
Top