Scottie vs Rory

[Highfade]

Brandel Chamblee in full rage bait mode on the PGA preview show.
Suggests that cherry picking Rory’s best year is still not as good as Scheffler.
And that Scheffler off his game is still miles clear of everyone, including Rory.

Is he off his meds or is he telling an uncomfortable truth?
There’s a subjective and objective element to this argument so it’s difficult to say definitively he’s ’wrong’.
What’s the argument to the contrary?

 

[GreiginFife]

if it’s rage bait then he’s certainly hooked you as you’re amplifying his addled thoughts.

There’s no logic to his assertion.

 

[IanM]

I try to avoid his output, so I wouldn't care. As I said somewhere else, you can tot up the wins when they have both finished.

For the record, I'd rather watch Rory blast it round, than watch Scottie any day. But who'd you pick for a Foursomes partner?

 

[Highfade]

if it’s rage bait then he’s certainly hooked you as you’re amplifying his addled thoughts.

There’s no logic to his assertion.

Maybe if he’s suggesting a scheffler C game vs Rory could be seen as a crazy take but I’m not so sure favouring Scottie in a prime v prime debate is that “addled”

 

[GreiginFife]

Maybe if he’s suggesting a scheffler C game vs Rory could be seen as a crazy take but I’m not so sure favouring Scottie in a prime v prime debate is that “addled”

He’s claiming Scottie “off his game” is miles clear of everyone. Logic dictates he’d win every week he teed up if that was the case.

The guy’s a ballsack.

 

[Lucifer MorningStar]

The only person worse on Golf programmes than Chamblee is McGinley. Getting them both together on the same show is less enjoyable than shoving wasps up your own backside.

Chamblee is doing what he always does spouting tripe to get conversation and clearly it’s work as here you are asking the question he posed. Prime Rory v Prime Scottie who cares just enjoy the golf they’re playing now. I don’t particularly care if either of them play well or badly I also couldn’t care less whose and World No1 with A, B, C or D games.

 

[IanM]

Indeed. Those two together was a weird selection process

 

[Orikoru]

I think Scottie having an off day is still clear of most of the field, as we've seen with some of his top tens, but not the likes Rory. That's just rage bait.

 

[mister v]

There both great players and scottie having an off day can probably still get a top 10 finish, where as rory having an off day would probably miss the cut. But i would pay my hard earned to follow rory around the course whereas im not bothered about scottie.