Opinion please.

need_my_wedge

Has Now Found His Wedgie
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
6,770
Location
Kingdom of Fife
Visit site
I played in a comp at the weekend, and actually played one of the best rounds I've ever done in a comp. Despite putting two 10's on the card, I came in with a net 76, so was quite happy. Of the two holes I shot badly, one was of my own making, whereby I opted for the "magic, I can do it" shot through and over the trees, rather than the percentage dig back into the middle. Ended up clipping a tree, trying again and deflecting OB yada yada - lesson learnt there.

My question is regarding the second 10. I was actually playing 4 onto the green when I thinned it pretty badly, it ran out the back down the slope and disappeared 30 yds down the hill in the next hole. There is a big line of tall staggered Pines between the holes and the hole runs downhill putting you about 20 - 40 feet lower than the ground level where the trees are growing. It cost me 4 shots trying to get back up the hill and through the trees onto the green.

When I was having a laugh about this in the clubhouse after, a friend of mine suggested two options next time I did the same (it's a common occurance on that hole for many, and is a heavy penalty to pay). He suggested that I either deem the ball lost or deem it unplayable and take a straight penalty drop back where I played the thinned shot.

I understand that this is within the rules, no different to a ball resting against a tree/ bush etc. But the fact that I can see the ball and swing a club at it makes me think it's a bit of a cheat.

Would you take the drop or play the 4 shots?
 
At any point, you can declare the ball unplayable, and under penalty go back and replay it. It's in the rules, so it's an option. One that I would take.
 
You can't deem a ball lost...it becomes lost when it can't be found within 5 minutes. You can deem a ball unplayable at any time, and yes you can go back and play from the same spot again under penalty on 1 stroke.
 
You can't deem a ball lost...it becomes lost when it can't be found within 5 minutes. You can deem a ball unplayable at any time, and yes you can go back and play from the same spot again under penalty on 1 stroke.
If you hit the thinned shot over the green, you can just drop another ball immediately (making sure NOT to declare it a provisional) and it automatically becomes the ball in play. You don't have to go and look for the first one before doing this.
 
Top