New irons fitting

fundy

Ryder Cup Winner
Joined
Aug 6, 2010
Messages
27,026
Location
Herts/Beds border
Visit site
***Warning: long post incoming***

As the weather seems to have put a block on getting outside and playing golf I decided now was as good a time as any to finally have a new irons fitting. Having spoke to a few guys on here as to what route to go I chose to go for a fitting with Orka (many thanks to GB72 who was able to put me in touch with a friend of his who is one of the top guys at Orka).

So last night I met Alex from Orka at one of their indoor fitting centres which is conveniently local to me in Milton Keynes with a view to an irons and a wedge fitting. the facility there has a GC2 monitor which seemed to measure every possible number/stat you could want on the golf swing.

Little background on Alex, whilst he is now a sales director he is also a qualified PGA pro and the initial warm up gave him a chance to get a look at my swing and also understand a bit about my golf. Alex is clearly passionate about golf, golf clubs and helping people play better golf (through better fitted clubs but also some swing advice).

After the warm up I hit some balls with my existing 6 iron to get a baseline to compare everything else to. The basic numbers were clubhead speed was 83mph, ball speed was 120mph and carry was 170 yards.

From there on, the fun began and it was time to try some new shinies :) Alex had built up many different 6 irons for me to try. In the Orka range of heads I was choosing between the RS1 (blade) RS3 (small cavity) and RS5 (cavity) all of which were forged iron heads.

http://www.orkagolf.com/products/irons/

The first thing to note was because of the chamfered (sp?) top edge their irons have it was almost impossible to tell the difference between the 3 options, and all were very appealing to the eye. A very classical looking iron, quite a short clubhead but they all looked very reassuring that they would be easy to hit.

After hitting balls with each club head it became apparent that for me there was little difference in performance level between the 3, personal preference ruled out the RS5 which left me with the bladed RS1 and the RS3. All 3 clubheads were as easy to hit as they looked (evens the blades!) I was adamant that whilst vanity would love a bladed set I should take the head over heart option of cavity backs for that bit of assistance. They all had that lovely soft feel of a decent forged iron but the blade just felt that little bit better. In the end I chose the compromise route of a split set. So I settled on 7iron to PW in the RS1s and 4-6iron in the RS3s.

From their we tried a variety of shafts (blind) and quickly ruled out a few, including the PX shaft that I currently have (too light and slightly too stiff) and from the stats we soon came down to 3 shafts that performed well for me. They were the KBS Tour, Orkas own NH9 Pro (made by FST) and the DG X100. After hitting some more balls (without knowing which shaft was which still) I ruled out the X100 which left it as a straight choice between the KBS Tour and the NH9 Pro. Based on the numbers and feel there was nothing to choose between them so based on cost I opted for the NH9 Pros (at this point Alex pointed out to me that both shafts were actually made by the same company FST). When Orka build a set of clubs, all shafts are pured as part of the process.

Next was some measurements to make sure the fit was perfect. The clubs I had been testing with were to my expected set up (1/2 inch longer and 2 degrees upright) and seemed ok but after checking some statics measurements and then hitting off a lie board we settled on 3/4 inch longer and 1 degree upright.

Next was grip and grip size and an area that Ive struggled with a bit of late. Having worried that actually my grip was now too big if anything it was actually on the small size and so I have gone from midsize to midsize plus 1 extra layer. Have decided to stay with the multicompounds as nothing else really appealed (having had corded grips since I was a kid find it hard to move away from at least part corded!).

Stats wise, the final set up when I hit on the GC2 were giving a clubhead speed of 85mph, ball speed of 125mph and a carry of 179 yards (so I had gained 9 yards), but far far more importantly to me was the dispersion has reduced greatly, the little circle with new clubs compared to old was almost half the size! Once I have had the clubs for a little bit Alex has invited me back to do a gap test on the machine and if there are any gaps that are too big or too small then lofts can be slightly adjusted to get the gaps spot on.

Next step was to look at adding some wedges and this was a very simple decision just to fit them with the set as the RS18 wedges are beautiful to look at to my eye and have a decently heavy feeling head. We talked for a while about shafts but Alex recommended keeping the shafts consistent with the irons (i was a little sceptical as last time I did this I didnt get on with the wedges, but if thats the case this time then the shafts can easily be changed to a normal wedge flex if required).

http://www.orkagolf.com/products/wedges/rs18-wedge/

I like to have plenty of options at this end of the bag so like to have 3 additional wedges and with the PW at 47 degrees the right options to me were to go up in 4 degree increments from there so a 52,56,60 set all delofted 1 degree seemed to be the right option, at least as a start point. Alex has agreed to include a wedge session on the machine for me to make sure that the lofts work for me and again to the get my yardages dialled in both for full shots but also for 1/2 and 3/4 shots.

Sadly my time being like a kid in a candy store was coming to an end (at least for now) but I can say what a thoroughly enjoyable and educational process the fitting was, the service level I received from Alex was nothing short of exceptional, its great to deal with someone so passionate and knowledgeable about their subject!

So all that remains is to pull the trigger and tell him to get them built. The sensible part of me had planned to wait until monday to make a decision but having written this Im pretty sure the next step is to contact Alex and tell him to start building!

Apologies for the length of post, hopefully some of you will have found it interesting, I will post again once I have the clubs and do a proper review, needless to say after the service levels I have received so far my expectation levels are very high for my new shinys :) Anyone has any questions I'll try and answer them albeit my recollection of the numbers may be a bit sketchy
 

Region3

Ryder Cup Winner
Joined
Aug 4, 2009
Messages
11,860
Location
Leicester
Visit site
Nice write up Steve.

Sounds like you had a good time there. I'm a little surprised that your swing speed isn't a little higher, having seen you play. Have you eased up on them recently?
 

fundy

Ryder Cup Winner
Joined
Aug 6, 2010
Messages
27,026
Location
Herts/Beds border
Visit site
Nice write up Steve.

Sounds like you had a good time there. I'm a little surprised that your swing speed isn't a little higher, having seen you play. Have you eased up on them recently?

Getting old Gary lol, but yes there has been a conscious effort to ease it down a level to add some more control. Last few months have spent some time shortening the back swing and reducing the amount of wrists in the swing which mean Ive given up a few yards
 

CMAC

Blackballed
Banned
Joined
Aug 5, 2011
Messages
15,121
Visit site
Very interesting- thanks :thup:


Pleasing to eye-Check
Great feeling at strike-Check
correct shaft now matched to you-Check
Gained extra yards-Check
Dispersion improved by 50%-Check
You are 100% happy-Check

...and the reason you've not ordered them is....?
 

GB72

Money List Winner
Joined
May 8, 2007
Messages
14,474
Location
Rutland
Visit site
didnt take long, ive done the right thing and pulled the trigger :)

Glad to hear that it went well and that the new shinies are ordered. I have had no regrets since buying mine and have since added a driver as well. Slowly but surely the bag is converting to Orka, 3 wood and wedges next.
 

Curls

Journeyman Pro
Joined
Mar 25, 2011
Messages
3,265
Visit site
Great write up chap, is it too vulgar to talk numbers on an open forum?! If so PM please! ;)

Not that I'm at the point where I could get as much out of this as you, but hopefully someday and when that day comes it'd be good to know what ballpark we're in (read "how much crawling to HID I need to do and how long a run up it will take")
 

bigslice

Tour Winner
Joined
Sep 3, 2009
Messages
4,704
Location
North Ayrshire
Visit site
***Warning: long post incoming***

As the weather seems to have put a block on getting outside and playing golf I decided now was as good a time as any to finally have a new irons fitting. Having spoke to a few guys on here as to what route to go I chose to go for a fitting with Orka (many thanks to GB72 who was able to put me in touch with a friend of his who is one of the top guys at Orka).

So last night I met Alex from Orka at one of their indoor fitting centres which is conveniently local to me in Milton Keynes with a view to an irons and a wedge fitting. the facility there has a GC2 monitor which seemed to measure every possible number/stat you could want on the golf swing.

Little background on Alex, whilst he is now a sales director he is also a qualified PGA pro and the initial warm up gave him a chance to get a look at my swing and also understand a bit about my golf. Alex is clearly passionate about golf, golf clubs and helping people play better golf (through better fitted clubs but also some swing advice).

After the warm up I hit some balls with my existing 6 iron to get a baseline to compare everything else to. The basic numbers were clubhead speed was 83mph, ball speed was 120mph and carry was 170 yards.

From there on, the fun began and it was time to try some new shinies :) Alex had built up many different 6 irons for me to try. In the Orka range of heads I was choosing between the RS1 (blade) RS3 (small cavity) and RS5 (cavity) all of which were forged iron heads.

http://www.orkagolf.com/products/irons/

The first thing to note was because of the chamfered (sp?) top edge their irons have it was almost impossible to tell the difference between the 3 options, and all were very appealing to the eye. A very classical looking iron, quite a short clubhead but they all looked very reassuring that they would be easy to hit.

After hitting balls with each club head it became apparent that for me there was little difference in performance level between the 3, personal preference ruled out the RS5 which left me with the bladed RS1 and the RS3. All 3 clubheads were as easy to hit as they looked (evens the blades!) I was adamant that whilst vanity would love a bladed set I should take the head over heart option of cavity backs for that bit of assistance. They all had that lovely soft feel of a decent forged iron but the blade just felt that little bit better. In the end I chose the compromise route of a split set. So I settled on 7iron to PW in the RS1s and 4-6iron in the RS3s.

From their we tried a variety of shafts (blind) and quickly ruled out a few, including the PX shaft that I currently have (too light and slightly too stiff) and from the stats we soon came down to 3 shafts that performed well for me. They were the KBS Tour, Orkas own NH9 Pro (made by FST) and the DG X100. After hitting some more balls (without knowing which shaft was which still) I ruled out the X100 which left it as a straight choice between the KBS Tour and the NH9 Pro. Based on the numbers and feel there was nothing to choose between them so based on cost I opted for the NH9 Pros (at this point Alex pointed out to me that both shafts were actually made by the same company FST). When Orka build a set of clubs, all shafts are pured as part of the process.

Next was some measurements to make sure the fit was perfect. The clubs I had been testing with were to my expected set up (1/2 inch longer and 2 degrees upright) and seemed ok but after checking some statics measurements and then hitting off a lie board we settled on 3/4 inch longer and 1 degree upright.

Next was grip and grip size and an area that Ive struggled with a bit of late. Having worried that actually my grip was now too big if anything it was actually on the small size and so I have gone from midsize to midsize plus 1 extra layer. Have decided to stay with the multicompounds as nothing else really appealed (having had corded grips since I was a kid find it hard to move away from at least part corded!).

Stats wise, the final set up when I hit on the GC2 were giving a clubhead speed of 85mph, ball speed of 125mph and a carry of 179 yards (so I had gained 9 yards), but far far more importantly to me was the dispersion has reduced greatly, the little circle with new clubs compared to old was almost half the size! Once I have had the clubs for a little bit Alex has invited me back to do a gap test on the machine and if there are any gaps that are too big or too small then lofts can be slightly adjusted to get the gaps spot on.

Next step was to look at adding some wedges and this was a very simple decision just to fit them with the set as the RS18 wedges are beautiful to look at to my eye and have a decently heavy feeling head. We talked for a while about shafts but Alex recommended keeping the shafts consistent with the irons (i was a little sceptical as last time I did this I didnt get on with the wedges, but if thats the case this time then the shafts can easily be changed to a normal wedge flex if required).

http://www.orkagolf.com/products/wedges/rs18-wedge/

I like to have plenty of options at this end of the bag so like to have 3 additional wedges and with the PW at 47 degrees the right options to me were to go up in 4 degree increments from there so a 52,56,60 set all delofted 1 degree seemed to be the right option, at least as a start point. Alex has agreed to include a wedge session on the machine for me to make sure that the lofts work for me and again to the get my yardages dialled in both for full shots but also for 1/2 and 3/4 shots.

Sadly my time being like a kid in a candy store was coming to an end (at least for now) but I can say what a thoroughly enjoyable and educational process the fitting was, the service level I received from Alex was nothing short of exceptional, its great to deal with someone so passionate and knowledgeable about their subject!

So all that remains is to pull the trigger and tell him to get them built. The sensible part of me had planned to wait until monday to make a decision but having written this Im pretty sure the next step is to contact Alex and tell him to start building!

Apologies for the length of post, hopefully some of you will have found it interesting, I will post again once I have the clubs and do a proper review, needless to say after the service levels I have received so far my expectation levels are very high for my new shinys :) Anyone has any questions I'll try and answer them albeit my recollection of the numbers may be a bit sketchy

how did they feel of the face to your current irons. and an approx cost would be helpfull
 

Ethan

Money List Winner
Joined
Jun 30, 2009
Messages
11,788
Location
Bearwood Lakes, Berks
Visit site
What flex of PX do you have now? Are they flighted or standard?

The stock shaft in the X Forged is the PXF 6.0. In my opinion, the TT DG X100 is a lot stiffer than that, as well as heavier and wouldn't be in the same conversation.

Swing speed with the 6 iron of 83-86 mph wouldn't put you in the range for X flex unless the tempo was lightning quick, and even then it mightn't be a good fit for other reasons. The carry distances for those swings also sound a little on the generous side.
 

fundy

Ryder Cup Winner
Joined
Aug 6, 2010
Messages
27,026
Location
Herts/Beds border
Visit site
What flex of PX do you have now? Are they flighted or standard?

The stock shaft in the X Forged is the PXF 6.0. In my opinion, the TT DG X100 is a lot stiffer than that, as well as heavier and wouldn't be in the same conversation.

Swing speed with the 6 iron of 83-86 mph wouldn't put you in the range for X flex unless the tempo was lightning quick, and even then it mightn't be a good fit for other reasons. The carry distances for those swings also sound a little on the generous side.

The existing shafts in the Xforgeds are 6.5s, the X100s felt no stiffer but definitely were heavier and felt better for the extra weight to me.

As for the speeds/distances I will get them sent through as I may have quoted them wrong but pretty sure they are what they were. The carry figures are about where I expected them to be (and the clubhead speed a little lower), obviously once I get the clubs will be able to confirm them on the course with a laser :)
 

Ethan

Money List Winner
Joined
Jun 30, 2009
Messages
11,788
Location
Bearwood Lakes, Berks
Visit site
The existing shafts in the Xforgeds are 6.5s, the X100s felt no stiffer but definitely were heavier and felt better for the extra weight to me.

As for the speeds/distances I will get them sent through as I may have quoted them wrong but pretty sure they are what they were. The carry figures are about where I expected them to be (and the clubhead speed a little lower), obviously once I get the clubs will be able to confirm them on the course with a laser :)

OK, PX 6.5 is a good bit firmer (roughly 7.0 on the Rifle scale) than PXF 6.0 (roughly 6.0 on the Rifle scale). But as with X100 (roughly 6.8 on the Rifle scale), PX 6.5 is not likely to suit very many players with 6 iron swing speed 83 to 86.
 
Last edited:

fundy

Ryder Cup Winner
Joined
Aug 6, 2010
Messages
27,026
Location
Herts/Beds border
Visit site
OK, PX 6.5 is a good bit firmer (roughly 7.0 on the Rifle scale) than PXF 6.0 (roughly 6.0 on the Rifle scale). But as with X100 (roughly 6.8 on the Rifle scale), PX 6.5 is not likely to suit very many players with 6 iron swing speed 83 to 86.

shouldve said they are 6.5 flighted Ethan


Seems my memory isnt great lol the average SS was 87mph peaking at 89mph, which prob explains Garys earlier comment too (hopefully will have full numbers from the fitter in the morning (as long as theyre still on the GC2)
 
Last edited:

Ethan

Money List Winner
Joined
Jun 30, 2009
Messages
11,788
Location
Bearwood Lakes, Berks
Visit site
shouldve said they are 6.5 flighted Ethan


Seems my memory isnt great lol the average SS was 87mph peaking at 89mph, which prob explains Garys earlier comment too (hopefully will have full numbers from the fitter in the morning (as long as theyre still on the GC2)

OK, that makes a bit more sense. PXF play about 0.5 softer than the same number PX, and the carry distances are more credible for those swing speeds. A KBS C-taper S might be worth looking at if you ever want a swap into something low spin and lowish launch.
 
Top