Is it worth getting a new SW?

[CheltenhamHacker]

So I've made a big mistake. I went a hit a few irons as part of a fitting, and as expected, the Ping G25's blew my current clubs out of the water. 1/3 of the side spin, a lot lower backspin (is this good though?), higher ball flight, and about 30 yards further!

This was all with the 7 iron.

My questions is just after some advice. The sets online sell 4-SW. I'm currently using the Cleveland 588 SW and really liking it, but mainly use it for shots 20 yards and in, rarely full shots. Do many people think it beneficial to have a SW of the same set, for consistency? Or do people stop at the PW and treat their wedges differently?

The pro shop have offered to open my current wedge up to 58* if I wanted, which would allow me to get rid of my cheap old lob wedge, if I wanted to SW from the new set.


Feel free to jump in with an opinion!

 

[Francisceo]

Bear in mind that I'm new to golf so my reply may sound silly - but I thought the SW should only be used when you're in a bunker????

 

[DappaDonDave]

Bear in mind that I'm new to golf so my reply may sound silly - but I thought the SW should only be used when you're in a bunker????

Ah, the innocence of a beginner...no a SW can be used when hitting a shot which is at the distance you hit your SW. Like using a 7 iron to chip around the green or a hybrid off the tee box. Golf is about using the tools you have.

 

[Francisceo]

Ah, the innocence of a beginner...no a SW can be used when hitting a shot which is at the distance you hit your SW. Like using a 7 iron to chip around the green or a hybrid off the tee box. Golf is about using the tools you have.

Got it.... Thanks for correcting me.

 

[Bratty]

The 588 is wonderful... can't think a Ping g25 would beat it.

Also, I didn't think that Ping sold stuff online, so be very careful of fakes.

 

[NorfolkShaun]

When buying a set of irons you can normally spec them as you choose so you could just leave the SW out and save a few quid.

 

[USER1999]

I would always buy specialist wedges, and not use the clunky ones that come with game improver sets. Just a personal preference, but I can vaguely accept a clunky 4 iron, but wedges are instruments, not hammers.

 

[HomerJSimpson]

Not a fan of the standard G25 SW (or PW) and I'd be looking for a specialist wedge. However if you are having any issues with bunkers, the extra bounce on the Ping may be a good thing. Horses for courses and best way is to try and test a few

 

[pbrown7582]

Dump the g25 sw wedge try snainton/clubhouse if buying online and keep the 588.
Also remember ping don't allow sales from legit dealers online you have to bring and confirm order off phone at least.
Can the shop not price match as ping will be custom fit.

 

[CheltenhamHacker]

Don't worry guys, I did know about Ping not doing online sales! I was just using proper websites to price match!

Ended up using the price from Carnoustie golf shop (ridiculously cheap) and Drayton Park Golf Course matched it for me! And I've gone 4-pw. Gonna keep my current sw, and think my step dad has a 53* utility I can use!

 

[SocketRocket]

The important issues with your wedges relate to the type of course you play, the type of sand and grass you will be hitting from.

If you are in Cheltenham I would recommend a visit to either: Graham Farr at Worcester Golf and Country Club, or, Rene Cleaver who is a master golf club fitter in Cheltenham. Both will give you some expert advice.

 

[Foxholer]

If you are in Cheltenham I would recommend a visit to either: Graham Farr at Worcester Golf and Country Club, or, Rene Cleaver who is a master golf club fitter in Cheltenham. Both will give you some expert advice.

Boy there's a name from the past!

Very experienced and highly recommended!

As for the original question...

I think you have done the best thing. There might be a case for a Gap wedge, say 50* but what you have done gives you more options at the top end without really restricting the scoring end.

 

[CheltenhamHacker]

Cheers SR! Unfortunately I've already ordered the new clubs, but next time round i will look up one of those two!!

The only decision i have now in my bag is either getting a driver, or filling the gap between my 3W and my 23* hybrid. Or getting both and losing the lob!