ColchesterFC
Journeyman Pro
With the discussion on the football thread about this I thought I'd post a poll to see what the consensus is. So which of the three players do you think was the best?
Gerrard, Scholes or Lampard. Who was best?
- Thread starter ColchesterFC
- Start date
Oohmeoldbacksknackered
Assistant Pro
Gerrard, end of discussion..
🤓
🤓
freddielong
Tour Winner
Who was best what?
Passer, goalscorer, tackler, at carrying a team, at making runs in to the box
Passer, goalscorer, tackler, at carrying a team, at making runs in to the box
ColchesterFC
Journeyman Pro
The best all round player. If your manager was looking to sign one of them - in their prime - which one would you want in your team over the other two?
Hacker Khan
Yurt Dwelling, Yoghurt Knitter
Pretty sure Xavi said Scholes was the best midfielder he'd seen in the last 20 years. So guess that is good enough for me.
ColchesterFC
Journeyman Pro
Well that's your opinion but the poll at the minute is showing that 4 Liverpool fans have voted for Gerrard and 4 non-Man Utd fans have voted for Scholes.
Tashyboy
Please don’t ask to see my tatts 👍
Struggling to pick one, but i will say that they were all excellent in there own teams, but put them in an England shirt and they were rammel. They could not play together no matter what positions they played. However two other greats Iniesta and Xavi could.
shagster
Head Pro
scholes or lampard
consistent at every level
gerrard - flat track bully. think graham hick
consistent at every level
gerrard - flat track bully. think graham hick
Blue in Munich
Crocked Professional Yeti Impersonator
How do we know who's voted for who, and therefore how accurate that is?
ColchesterFC
Journeyman Pro
Results are public so you can click on the total votes for one option and it shows you who voted for each one.
TonyN
Money List Winner
Scholes was a different class to them both. And they are both outstanding players in their own right.
Scholes never bottled a title either.
Scholes never bottled a title either.
shagster
Head Pro
neither did lampard
different style but should have been the england midfield for many years, but poor management and selections
Lamps
Scholes
Slippy
Scholes
Slippy
Beezerk
Money List Winner
Gazza 😅
HomerJSimpson
Hall of Famer
All three were top players in their own rights and had their own talents that made their sides better for having them. I can't separate Lampard and Gerrard as my top dog though
Beezerk is right. Maybe the title should be more specific and ask who is the best between these three 😁. This is really an argument between fans of Liverpool, man Utd and Chelsea.
freddielong
Tour Winner
Out of the 3 Scholes was the best for me, all 3 played different styles so hard to compare.
If I had to pick a midfielder from the past it would be Vieira.
If I had to pick a midfielder from the past it would be Vieira.
U
User62651
Guest
Different strengths and a tough call but I went Scholes overall, not much in it but Scholes' sheer passing distribution/accuracy, workrate and toughness in the tackle would make me pick him for my team if I had the luxury of choosing only 1 of the 3 in their prime. Would take any of em to be fair.
