A tough, tough choice...

Hobbit

Mordorator
Moderator
Joined
Sep 11, 2011
Messages
20,788
Location
Espana
Visit site
Forumites, your opinions would be greatly appreciated.

Short version; our much loved dog is ill. Final test results came through on Saturday morning, basically confirming what we'd been told a week ago, in terms of diagnosis.

1) Chemo will give her a year. And a year to a dog is a long time. But the vet says it won't give a decent quality of life. He wouldn't do it to his dog.

2) Palliative care will give 2-4 weeks. During that time we have to watch her for side effects from the meds, and decide if they are limiting her quality of life further. We will also, with the vets help, have to determine when is best to "make her comfortable."

3) "Make her comfortable" now.

We've chosen option 2, but getting the balance right for her is almost a finger in the wind exercise. Yesterday, although not bounding with energy was a better day, and she ate exceptionally well. Late evening was uncomfortable for her and it was a bad night but she ate well this morning, and wagged her tail when I was prep-ing her breakfast.

She barked her displeasure when I left for work, for the first time in a couple of weeks. However, her uncomfortable times are worse than a week ago.

We have our head around the decision, but its the when we are struggling with... HID is in the sooner rather than later camp, and I'm trying to manage it on a day by day, minute by minute thing. But what we have to keep to the forefront of our minds is its what's best for Bess, not what's best for us.

Thanks for reading, and ALL opinions not matter how brutal are welcome.
 
Oh crap that has reduced me to tears. We went through similar last year with our beloved boy Max and it broke our hearts - still feels very, very raw. His last few months, weeks, days were in the main pretty good but I was so worried about when to make "the" decision and so worried I'd let him down when he needed me most. Those who had been in the same situation all said the same "you'll know...he'll let you know when" and they were right. I can't type the detail of that final day as I'm at work and will be a total blubbering mess but I knew it was the right time even though I'd taken him to see the vet hoping he'd still come home...

So option 2 without any doubt...you'll do the right thing for her and I'd say right now that's enjoying the time you have left.
 
Sorry to read that Bri

Option 2 would be my choice and agree see how she goes on a day to day basis and have her needs fully in the forefront. Sad news

She will let you know when it's time to go
 
Tough one for sure but If it were me Brian I think I'd choose to put her to sleep now.

Options 1-2 will be too painful and distressful for Bess and you all.

No matter what you choose to do though you will ultimately be making a decision that is right for Bess so don't beat yourself up about it.
 
We went down option two for Baldrick, he is still going strong and is post the two months the vets gave him back at the end of Jan.

we are just trying to make his last days as happy as we can.

our thoughts are with all
 
I've been in a similar situation and I ended up opting for option 3. I just couldn't watch him struggling to stand up and I occasionally felt like I was making the decision more about my suffering than his..

One of the hardest things I've ever had to do and I'm not ashamed to say that I cried like a baby when his eyes closed for good.. We still have his picture around the house, and his collar/lead under the stairs..

I really feel for you having to make this decision.. Hope that you find peace with whichever decision you make...
 
You have obviously considered things carefully and care about how your decision affects your dog, so trust yourself and your judgement as you will know when the time has come.
 
Its always a sad time but option 2 Brian I think

We had two cats (brothers) and they lived way beyond the normal life expectancy. I took one to the vets on 3 separate occasions and bought him back twice as I didn't feel the time was right.

You'll just know Brian!
 
Sorry to hear this mate,

Option 2, however get ready to step in quickly with Option 3, you'll know when it's time.
 
Brian, sorry to hear the bad news for you and the family.
This is a really hard decision and no matter which one you make , you will always be asking yourself if you made the right one.

One of my last pets , Barney ( a rescue staffy) he was with us for 8 years before being striken with cancer. He hated the vets and also would rip any stiches out after a op.

We made the very hard decision that he would not have a good quality of life if we went ahead with the treatment and in the end he was put to sleep. I cried more that day than when my gran died. I still get sad thinking about it.

At the end of the day everyone will have there own views mate. What ever decision is made will be hard but will be the correct one.

Again sorry to hear the news.
 
Yep! Option 2, but be ready for Option 3 when it becomes obvious!

My mate had/has the same issue with his (nearly 10yo) Cocker. It's a guess whether the Cancer or a glitch in his back (possibly more Cancer) will get him first, but the meds are keeping him happily pain free and pretty much as mad as ever at the moment! I'll be saying my goodbye to him this weekend!
 
My mum chose option 3 for our cat when the time came. she knew neither myself or my dad would be strong enough to do it. She was the only one available and made the call. My dad and I probably would have gone for option 2.


I would never put a pet through long term chemo treatment. Sorry folks but that is only thinking of one person and it isn't the animal.
 
Heartbreaking to hear mate but yeah I would still go with option 2 as long as he can enjoy(in as much as expected) his final weeks with the family. Thoughts are with you
 
Option 3. Don't feel guilty.

I'm still traumatised by two long time pet cats being put down after illnesses. No fun watching them deteriorate and decline. We were quicker to option 3 with the second cat.
 
Dont judge the comfort of your dog by their appettite. I know of a few instances when they are eating well, but still in a lot of pain. Dogs do their best to hide pain, its built-in

Give them the pain meds and when you see the signs of them experiencing pain then put them down ASAP. Easier said than done, and I have shed many tears on that point, but its the compassionate and unselfish thing to do. Animals shouldnt suffer longer than they need to because we are struggling to deal with something.

Google dog's handling pain or something similar and you will see the other symptoms, the most common one is them just staring at the wall or a door.

Good luck a terrible thing to go through
 
Horrible experience for you and the family, but even more horrible for the dog.

Very difficult to choose between options 2 and 3, I guess only you'll know when the time is right to send her off.

All the best
 
Top