Dunesman's latest activity

  • D
    Dunesman replied to the thread Official WHS Survey.
    I thought handicaps were to be consistent across the world was the fundamental justification ? Not that we were missing slope in the UK.
  • D
    Dunesman replied to the thread Official WHS Survey.
    With what aim though. WHS was to unify and have comparable handicaps across the globe. In that, they are no further on, so have failed...
  • D
    Dunesman replied to the thread Official WHS Survey.
    While they will probably never hear of it even when implemented so will be none the wiser, they dont allow in theory anyway, clubs to...
  • D
    Dunesman replied to the thread Official WHS Survey.
    Why not a change to the .95 factor ? Already catered for in WHS, just hobbled locally. The dont need a survey to crunch tge numbers.
  • D
    Dunesman replied to the thread Official WHS Survey.
    The procedure itself may be perfectly fine. But they made the change, without foreseeing the collateral damage outside the tiny minority...
  • D
    Dunesman replied to the thread Official WHS Survey.
    The message received, is gp scores aare questionable in the eyes of EG.
  • D
    Dunesman replied to the thread Official WHS Survey.
    I am not misunderstanding it. I dont even know it. That is my point. That something/whatever, was implemented to have a distinctuon...
  • D
    Dunesman replied to the thread Official WHS Survey.
    You may well be correct, but the fine print doesnt really matter in the wider perception of what they did, not that it is relevant to...
  • D
    Dunesman replied to the thread Official WHS Survey.
    Then they aren't. They are Junior Members. Not Members. That is not inconsistent.
  • D
    Dunesman replied to the thread Official WHS Survey.
    The step change improver has always been an imperfection in handicap systems, and it is no different under WHS really. On the positive...
  • D
    Dunesman replied to the thread Official WHS Survey.
    We let juniors play in the adult competitions, with the limitation that ; they must have a full 20 cards history, none of which can be 9...
  • D
    Dunesman replied to the thread Official WHS Survey.
    It looks like the UK regions themselves are not really trusting the handicaps either when it comes to the competitions the same as EG...
  • D
    Dunesman replied to the thread Official WHS Survey.
    Why so negative ? Maybe the fix isnt so radical. Just a tweak of the fixed values in the same fundamental formula. Like soft cap applies...
  • D
    Dunesman replied to the thread Official WHS Survey.
    The point is that much of the history of club comps here was structured on no categories. It worked. Board comps and historic trophies...
  • D
    Dunesman replied to the thread Official WHS Survey.
    The problem is that it applies to all clubs, not just some. Yes, only some players within those clubs - tge 23 index man hasnt felt its...
Top